The best thing I got anywhere near your area was a broken Capcom Fighter Stick with an SNES cable for a buck, at the Canton Salvation Army Thrift. Someone cracked the board. I can fix it. I'm like OCP.
Come up northeast a bit. Youngstown's Goodwill, Warren's Goodwill and Sally Army, and very rarely Andover's Goodwill have occasionally decent stuff. Actually, Warren is afflicted with the dreaded EBAY PRICES IN THE REAL WORLD disease. $120 for a used Gamecube? Good luck with that.

But I digress. Ye've got the greatest of luck, yardsaling in the belly of the beast. Keeraist, nothing but overpriced junk out here. And the absurdly cheap that I didn't buy, then sorely regretted for years to come. Hahah... Oh god, I need a drink.